writing-tests

Writing Tests for opencode-swarm

⚠️ Do NOT use the OpenCode test_runner tool to validate the full repo. It is for targeted agent validation with explicit files: [...] or small targeted scopes. scope: 'all' is gated behind the SWARM_ALLOW_FULL_SUITE=1 env var (intended for opt-in CI mirrors only; there is no allow_full_suite arg). Broad scopes can stall or kill OpenCode before the MAX_SAFE_TEST_FILES = 50 guard in src/tools/test-runner.ts fires. For repo validation, use the shell commands in this file — per-file isolation loops match CI behavior. See AGENTS.md invariant 6 for the full contract.

⛔ STOP — Read Before Running Any Tests

test_runner scope safety — one rule, no exceptions:

If you need to run tests across multiple source files: use a per-file shell loop, not test_runner.

Truncated output recovery: When bun test output exceeds the bash tool buffer it is saved to a file whose ID (tool_abc123...) cannot be retrieved via retrieve_summary (which only accepts S1, S2 format). Workaround — pipe to a temp file instead:

# PowerShell (Windows)
bun --smol test tests/unit/agents --timeout 60000 | Out-File "$env:TEMP\test_out.txt"; Get-Content "$env:TEMP\test_out.txt" | Select-Object -Last 30

# bash (Linux/macOS)
bun --smol test tests/unit/agents --timeout 60000 2>&1 | tee /tmp/test_out.txt | tail -30

Framework: bun:test Only

All test files MUST import from bun:test:

import { describe, test, expect, beforeEach, afterEach } from 'bun:test';

Bun provides a vitest compatibility layer (vi.mock, vi.fn, vi.spyOn) that works on Linux and macOS. However, vi.mock() has critical isolation bugs in Bun when multiple test directories run in the same process. Prefer bun:test native APIs:

Mock Isolation Rules

CRITICAL: Module-level mocks leak across test files within the same Bun process.

Bun's --smol mode shares the module cache between test files in the same worker process. A mock.module() call in file A replaces the module globally — file B gets the mock instead of the real module. This caused ~959 failures before per-file isolation was added (#330).

Additional critical limitation (Bun v1.3.11): mock.restore() does NOT reliably restore mock.module mocks. Cross-module mocks can persist across test boundaries even after afterEach(mock.restore()) is called. Three layers of defense are required.

Rules

1. Spread the real module when mocking. Only override the specific export you need:

import * as realChildProcess from 'node:child_process';
const mockExecFileSync = mock(() => '');
mock.module('node:child_process', () => ({
  ...realChildProcess,          // preserve all other exports
  execFileSync: mockExecFileSync, // override only what you test
}));

This prevents tests from accidentally nullifying exports that other code depends on. This is mandatory for Node built-ins (node:fs, node:fs/promises, node:child_process, etc.) because other code imports the full module — returning a partial mock without spreading real exports breaks unrelated imports.

2. Use lazy binding in source code. Import the namespace, call methods at invocation time:

// GOOD — mockable via mock.module
import * as child_process from 'node:child_process';
function run() { return child_process.execFileSync('git', ['status']); }

// BAD — binds at module load, mock.module can't intercept
import { execFileSync } from 'node:child_process';

3. Always add afterEach(mock.restore()) for cross-module mocks. Even though it is unreliable in Bun v1.3.11, it provides best-effort cleanup and reduces the window of cross-file contamination. Without it, the mock persists until the process exits:

import { afterEach, mock } from 'bun:test';

afterEach(() => {
  mock.restore();
});

Exception — Windows EBUSY: Test files that spawn async child processes (e.g. pre-check-batch tests) must NOT call mock.restore() on Windows. Child process handles can hold directory locks, and mock.restore() triggers cleanup that causes EBUSY errors. These files must use describe.skipIf(process.platform === 'win32') or test.skipIf(process.platform === 'win32') for affected tests.

Intentionally skipped on Windows (async child process handles cause EBUSY):

• tests/unit/tools/pre-check-batch-sast-preexisting.test.ts
• tests/unit/tools/pre-check-batch.adversarial.test.ts
• tests/unit/tools/pre-check-batch-cwd.test.ts
• tests/unit/tools/pre-check-batch-cwd.adversarial.test.ts
• tests/unit/tools/pre-check-batch-contextdir-adversarial.test.ts
• tests/unit/tools/pre-check-batch-secretscan-evidence.test.ts
• tests/unit/tools/pre-check-batch.test.ts

4. Never create circular mock imports. This pattern deadlocks Bun:

// BROKEN — imports from the module it's about to mock
import { realFn } from '../../src/module.js';
vi.mock('../../src/module.js', () => ({
  realFn: (...args) => realFn(...args),  // circular!
  otherFn: vi.fn(),
}));

Instead, inline the function logic or extract the real functions into a separate utility module.

5. Prefer constructor/parameter injection over module mocking. The swarm's hook factories (createScopeGuardHook, createDelegationLedgerHook, etc.) accept injected dependencies — test them by passing mock callbacks, not by replacing modules.

6. Mock validateDirectory when testing with Windows temp paths. The path-security.ts validator rejects Windows absolute paths (C:\...). If your test uses os.tmpdir() and passes that path to a function that calls validateDirectory, mock it:

mock.module('../../../src/utils/path-security', () => ({
  validateDirectory: () => {},
  validateSwarmPath: (p: string) => p,
}));

Diagnosing Test Isolation Failures

When test files pass individually but fail when run together, follow this protocol:

1. Isolate: Run the failing file alone: bun test <file>.test.ts --timeout 30000
2. Pair: Run it WITH its suspected polluting neighbor: bun test <fileA>.test.ts <fileB>.test.ts
3. Classify:
   • Both pass alone → fail together → mock pollution from neighbor
   • Fails alone → test logic bug (not isolation issue)
   • Passes alone + passes together but fails in full suite → third-file pollution (use binary search across directory)
4. For mock pollution, check the neighbor for these patterns:
   • vi.mock() or mock.module() inside beforeEach() (not at top level)
   • delete require.cache[...] combined with re-import pattern
   • These indicate hoist-time closure capture — see below
5. Specific symptom — closure capture failure: vi.mock() captures closures at hoist time (before beforeEach runs). Reassigning mockFn.mockImplementation(newFn) in the test body does NOT update the hoisted closure — the mock still calls the original function.
   • Symptom: expect(mockFn).toHaveBeenCalledTimes(N) fails with an unexpected count
   • Symptom: expect(mockFn).not.toHaveBeenCalled() fails because the real function was called
6. Fix path: Migrate the affected test file to the _internals DI seam pattern documented above (opencode-swarm repository contributors also have a dedicated mock-to-internals-migration skill that walks the recipe in depth). This eliminates both the vi.mock() call and the closure capture surface area. Exception — reference-captured functions: if the source code passes a function as a direct argument or captures it in a closure at module scope (e.g., transactFile(path, readKnowledge, ...)), the reference bypasses _internals entirely — mutating _internals.readKnowledge changes only the object property, not the module-scope binding the source already holds. Migrating to _internals does not help. In that case, test via observable outcomes (e.g., run concurrent callers and assert on final persisted state).

Two-Tier Mock Convention

The codebase uses a two-tier strategy for mock isolation, plus a zero-mock testing pattern:

Tier 0: _test_exports Pure Function Testing (Zero Mocks)

When a module contains internal utility functions (formatters, normalizers, transformers) that don't need external dependencies, export them via a _test_exports object for direct unit testing. This avoids mock.module entirely and produces tests that are deterministic, fast, and immune to Bun's cross-file mock leakage:

// In source file (src/tools/formatter.ts)
function formatEntry(entry: SomeType): string {
  // internal implementation — may use optional chaining, defaults, etc.
  return entry.score?.toFixed(2) ?? 'N/A';
}

// Public API (tool handler, command handler, etc.)
export function handleQuery(ctx: Context) {
  const entries = readData(ctx);
  return entries.map(formatEntry);
}

// Export seam for testing — only used by test files
export const _test_exports = { formatEntry };

// In test file (tests/unit/tools/formatter.test.ts)
import { _test_exports } from '../../../src/tools/formatter';

const { formatEntry } = _test_exports;

describe('formatEntry', () => {
  test('handles missing score', () => {
    expect(formatEntry({ score: undefined })).toBe('N/A');
  });
  test('formats numeric score', () => {
    expect(formatEntry({ score: 0.85 })).toBe('0.85');
  });
});

When to use Tier 0 vs Tier 1:

• Tier 0 (_test_exports): The function is a pure utility (formatter, normalizer, transformer) that doesn't call external modules. No mocking needed — test it directly.
• Tier 1 (_internals): You need to mock a function within the same module to test the caller in isolation. The function has side effects or calls external APIs.
• Tier 2 (mock.module): You need to mock a dependency from another module (Node built-ins, other application modules).

Benefits of Tier 0:

• Zero mock pollution — no mock.module calls, no mock.restore() needed
• Works in batch test runs without per-file isolation
• Type-safe (the exported object carries the real TypeScript types)
• No filesystem dependencies (no tmpDir, no chdir, no existsSync)
• Deterministic on all platforms and CI environments

Tier 1: _internals DI Seams (Within-Module)

For mocking functions within the same module, source files export an _internals object that wraps key functions. Tests can replace individual functions without using mock.module:

// In source file (src/services/my-service.ts)
export const _internals = {
  helperFn: () => { /* real implementation */ }
};

export function mainFn() {
  return _internals.helperFn();
}

// In test file
import { _internals, mainFn } from '../../../src/services/my-service';

test('mainFn uses mocked helper', () => {
  const original = _internals.helperFn;
  _internals.helperFn = mock(() => 'mocked');
  // ... test ...
  _internals.helperFn = original; // restore
});

Benefits:

• No process-global mock pollution
• Type-safe
• Fast (no module re-parsing)
• Works in batch test runs without isolation

Critical limitation — reference-captured functions: _internals interception requires the source code to read _internals.fn at the call site. When a function is instead passed as a direct argument or captured in a closure at module definition time, replacing _internals.fn has no effect — the mock is silently ignored and the real function runs.

// Source: readKnowledge is captured at definition time, NOT via _internals
export async function transactKnowledge(filePath: string, mutate: Fn) {
  return transactFile(filePath, readKnowledge, ...);  // direct ref, captured at definition time
}
export const _internals = { readKnowledge };  // mutating this does NOT affect the closure above

// Test — mock is silently ignored; real readKnowledge still runs
const orig = _internals.readKnowledge;
_internals.readKnowledge = mock(() => []);  // only mutates the object property
await transactKnowledge(path, mutate);      // still calls the real readKnowledge
_internals.readKnowledge = orig;

When _internals interception cannot work, verify observable outcomes instead: run concurrent callers and assert on final persisted state. See tests/unit/hooks/knowledge-application.test.ts ("two concurrent bumpCountersBatch calls") for the pattern.

Tier 2: mock.module (Cross-Module)

When mocking dependencies from other modules (especially Node built-ins), use mock.module with proper cleanup:

import * as realFs from 'node:fs/promises';

mock.module('node:fs/promises', () => ({
  ...realFs,  // MUST spread real exports
  readFile: mock(() => Promise.resolve('mocked')),
}));

afterEach(() => mock.restore());

Critical rules for cross-module mocks:

1. Always spread real exports for Node built-ins — other code depends on exports you don't mock
2. Always add afterEach(mock.restore()) — provides best-effort cleanup
3. Run in per-file isolation — CI runs each file in its own process (for f in *.test.ts; do bun --smol test "$f"; done)

Choosing Between Tiers

Mock Coverage Documentation

When a test fixture mocks fewer than 100% of a target function's branches, the test MUST document, in a comment, which paths/branches are untested and the rationale for not covering them. Partial-coverage mock decisions must be explicit and reviewable instead of silent.

Why this matters

A narrow mock can produce hollow coverage: the test passes because the mocked path returns a favorable result, but downstream branches that the real code would exercise remain untested. When the unmocked branches later fail, the failure is misdiagnosed as an unrelated regression because the test appeared to cover the caller.

Motivating case: tests/unit/turbo/lean/runtime-conformance.test.ts:457 mocks only readCriticEvidence → APPROVED, leaving downstream gates (retrospective evidence, drift-verifier, completion-verify) unmocked. The assertion expect(parsed.status).not.toBe('blocked') passed, but coverage was hollow. A later failure was initially misdiagnosed as an unrelated minification regression because the test gave false confidence that the caller's gate sequence was exercised.

Required comment format

For any mock that does not cover all branches of the target function, add a comment near the mock declaration listing:

1. Which branches/paths are untested.
2. Why they are not covered in this test (e.g., "covered by runtime-conformance.complete.test.ts", "requires live critic evidence store", "tested at integration level in tests/integration/...").

// Example — partial mock with documented coverage gap
mock.module('../../../src/turbo/lean/runtime-conformance', () => ({
  ...realModule,
  // readCriticEvidence mocked to APPROVED only.
  // Untested branches: RETRY, REJECT, and the downstream gates
  // (retrospective evidence, drift-verifier, completion-verify) that
  // depend on non-APPROVED critic verdicts. Rationale: those paths
  // are covered by tests/unit/turbo/lean/runtime-conformance.complete.test.ts.
  readCriticEvidence: mock(() => 'APPROVED'),
}));

This requirement applies to all three mock tiers (_test_exports, _internals, mock.module) whenever the mock narrows the exercised branch set.

mock.module() Export Completeness

When using mock.module() (or vi.mock()) with Bun's test runner, the mock factory MUST provide stubs for ALL named exports of the target module — not just the ones your test calls. Bun validates the export set at dynamic-import time and throws SyntaxError: Export named 'X' not found if any export is missing.

Why this matters

Transitive imports may reference exports your test never calls directly. For example, if your test mocks config/schema.js and only uses stripKnownSwarmPrefix, but a transitive dependency imports PluginConfigSchema from the same module, the mock MUST include PluginConfigSchema as a stub — even though your test never calls it.

When the source module gains new exports (e.g., a PR adds 50 new Zod schemas to config/schema.ts), ALL existing mock.module() calls targeting that module must be updated — even if the new exports are irrelevant to your test.

How to verify completeness

Before finalizing a test that uses mock.module():

1. List all runtime exports of the target module (type-only exports are erased at compile time and need no stub):

   grep -E "^export (const|function|async function|class) " src/path/to/module.ts
   

   Note: Do NOT include type or interface exports — Bun erases these at compile time and they need no runtime stub.
2. Ensure every export name has an entry in your mock.module() factory.
3. Stubs can be minimal:
   • Functions: () => null or async () => {}
   • Zod schemas: use a comprehensive stub that supports common methods:

     const zodStub = {
       parse: (v: unknown) => v,
       safeParse: (v: unknown) => ({ success: true as const, data: v }),
       parseAsync: async (v: unknown) => v,
     };
     

   • Constants: appropriate zero values ('', 0, null, [], {})

Verification pattern

// ✅ CORRECT — all exports provided, test uses only the first one
mock.module('../../../src/config/schema.js', () => ({
  // The one export your test actually uses
  stripKnownSwarmPrefix: mockStripFn,
  // Stubs for transitive import resolution (never called in test)
  PluginConfigSchema: zodStub,
  ScoringConfigSchema: zodStub,
  isKnownCanonicalRole: () => false,
  // ... all other runtime exports as stubs
}));

// ❌ WRONG — missing exports cause SyntaxError at module-load time
mock.module('../../../src/config/schema.js', () => ({
  stripKnownSwarmPrefix: mockStripFn,
  // Missing: PluginConfigSchema, ScoringConfigSchema, etc.
  // → "SyntaxError: Export named 'PluginConfigSchema' not found"
}));

What IS and IS NOT test theater

Adding stubs for ESM resolution is NOT test theater — it's a Bun runtime requirement. The distinction:

The stubs exist solely to satisfy the module loader. Test assertions must verify behavior through the real-mocked functions (the ones your test actually calls), not through the stubs.

Files Intentionally Using File-Scoped Mocks

Some test files use top-level mock.module that must persist across all tests in the file. These files use mockReset()/mockClear() in beforeEach instead of mock.restore() in afterEach:

• src/__tests__/preflight-phase.test.ts — mocks plan/manager and preflight-service

Cross-Platform Test Patterns

Tests run on all three CI platforms (ubuntu, macos, windows). Path and filesystem behavior differs between them. Follow these patterns to prevent platform-specific failures:

Mock keys with filesystem paths

Never hardcode Unix-format paths as mock keys. On Windows, path.resolve('/dir', 'file') produces drive-letter-prefixed paths like D:\dir\file, not /dir/file. A mock that checks for /dir/file will silently never match, causing the test to behave differently on Windows.

Use path.resolve() to construct mock keys the same way the source code does:

// ❌ WRONG — fails on Windows (mock expects '/safe/dir/linked.ts',
//    but path.resolve('/safe/dir', 'linked.ts') = 'D:\safe\dir\linked.ts')
mockRealpathSync.mockImplementation((inputPath: string) => {
  if (inputPath === '/safe/dir') return '/safe/dir';
  if (inputPath === '/safe/dir/linked.ts') return '/outside/linked.ts';
  return inputPath;
});

// ✅ CORRECT — path.resolve produces matching keys on all platforms
const mockDir = path.resolve('/safe/dir');
const linkedResolved = path.resolve(mockDir, 'linked.ts');
const outsideResolved = path.resolve('/outside/linked.ts');

// mockRealpathSync is a mock() function (bun:test) — see mocking patterns above
mockRealpathSync.mockImplementation((inputPath: string) => {
  if (inputPath === mockDir) return mockDir;
  if (inputPath === linkedResolved) return outsideResolved;
  return inputPath;
});

Symlink behavior differences

• On Windows, fs.symlinkSync for directories creates junctions by default, which resolve differently than POSIX symlinks. Junction creation may require administrator elevation on older Node.js versions.
• fs.realpathSync on a broken symlink throws ENOENT on POSIX but may throw EINVAL on Windows, depending on symlink type.
• Use test.skipIf(process.platform === 'win32') for tests that directly manipulate filesystem symlinks, unless the test's purpose is explicitly to verify cross-platform symlink behavior.

Temporary directory patterns

• Use os.tmpdir() + path.join() for temp paths. Never hardcode /tmp or C:\.
• Wrap mkdtempSync in realpathSync if the result is chdir'd on macOS (temp dirs are often symlinked to /private/var/...).
• Clean up temp dirs in afterEach or afterAll with a bounded helper that verifies the resolved cleanup target is a child of os.tmpdir() before calling recursive rm. Reuse tests/helpers/safe-test-dir.ts when possible. Do not call recursive rm on a computed path unless the helper has rejected empty strings, os.tmpdir() itself, and paths outside the temp root.

Platform-specific environment variable redirection

When tests redirect process.env.HOME to isolate path-resolver-dependent code (functions like resolveHiveKnowledgePath, resolveSwarmKnowledgePath, or any function that reads os.homedir() / platform env vars), they MUST redirect ALL platform-specific env vars, not just HOME. A partial redirect silently falls back to the real user profile on some platforms, causing tests to read/write actual user data instead of the isolated temp directory.

Per-platform requirements:

• Linux: redirect HOME, XDG_CONFIG_HOME, and XDG_DATA_HOME.
• macOS: redirect HOME (macOS resolves ~/Library/Application Support from the home directory).
• Windows: redirect HOME, LOCALAPPDATA, AND APPDATA. Windows path resolvers read LOCALAPPDATA and APPDATA, neither of which is derived from HOME. Redirecting only HOME silently fails on Windows, causing tests to touch the real %LOCALAPPDATA% and %APPDATA% trees.

⚠️ Bun caches os.homedir() on first call. If a module calls os.homedir() before the test sets process.env.HOME, the cached value persists for the lifetime of the process and later env changes are silently ignored. Set process.env.HOME (and other redirected vars) before importing any module that calls os.homedir(). The source code documents this at src/hooks/knowledge-store.ts: "Bun caches os.homedir(), so changing $HOME after first call is ignored."

Use per-variable save/restore rather than saving and replacing the entire process.env object — the latter discards process-level env state and can interfere with other test infrastructure:

import { beforeEach, afterEach } from 'bun:test';
import os from 'node:os';
import path from 'node:path';

const saved = {
  HOME: process.env.HOME,
  LOCALAPPDATA: process.env.LOCALAPPDATA,
  APPDATA: process.env.APPDATA,
  XDG_CONFIG_HOME: process.env.XDG_CONFIG_HOME,
  XDG_DATA_HOME: process.env.XDG_DATA_HOME,
};

beforeEach(() => {
  const isolatedDir = path.join(os.tmpdir(), 'test-home');
  process.env.HOME = isolatedDir;
  process.env.LOCALAPPDATA = isolatedDir;
  process.env.APPDATA = isolatedDir;
  process.env.XDG_CONFIG_HOME = isolatedDir;
  process.env.XDG_DATA_HOME = isolatedDir;
});

afterEach(() => {
  for (const [key, value] of Object.entries(saved)) {
    if (value === undefined) delete process.env[key];
    else process.env[key] = value;
  }
});

For cross-file isolation (tests that must survive across multiple files in the same process, e.g. batch steps), use beforeAll / afterAll with the same per-var save/restore pattern. Never mutate process.env without restoring it in a matching teardown hook.

Preferred approach: Use createIsolatedTestEnv() from tests/helpers/isolated-test-env.ts. It handles XDG_CONFIG_HOME, APPDATA, LOCALAPPDATA, and HOME with correct per-variable save/restore and returns a cleanup function that removes the temp directory. Use this helper unless your test has specific requirements it doesn't cover.

Line ending normalization

Git on Windows converts LF to CRLF by default. Tests that compare file contents byte-by-byte against expected strings must normalize line endings:

const actual = readFileSync(path, 'utf-8').replace(/\r\n/g, '\n');

CI Pipeline Structure

The CI runs on three platforms (ubuntu, macos, windows). Tests are split into 6 logical steps within each platform's job. (CI distributes files across shards via round-robin — see TESTING.md's CI Pipeline Steps table for the authoritative directory lists.)

Step 1a: hooks (mock.module files — 15 files) — per-file isolation (dedicated step)
Step 1b: hooks (remaining groups)               — per-file loop per group
Step 2:  cli                                     — batch
Step 3:  commands, config                        — batch
Step 4:  tools                                   — per-file loop
Step 5:  services, build, quality, sast, sbom, scripts — per-file loop
Step 6:  adversarial, agents, background, context, diff, evidence, git, helpers,
         knowledge, lang, output, parallel, plan, session, skills, types, utils — per-file loop

Per-file isolation (steps 1a, 1b, 4-6): each .test.ts file runs in its own bun --smol process to prevent mock.module() cache poisoning (#330). Steps 2-3 run files in batch because they have fewer mock conflicts. CI partitions the gated test set into 6 shards round-robin per platform (no hardcoded file lists), with a per-file retry budget (two retries / three attempts before a failure is treated as real) and quarantine filters (scripts/ci/quarantined-tests.txt, plus -macos/-windows overrides) that drop known pre-existing failures.

When writing a test, know which step your file will run in. In batch steps, do not assume isolation from other files in the same step.

Job timeout: 40 minutes. A hanging shard will kill the entire platform's test run; the per-file run-test-with-timeout.ts wrapper caps each file at 120 s (180 s kill-timeout).

File Placement

Convention

Naming

• Base test: <module>.test.ts
• Adversarial variant: <module>.adversarial.test.ts

Only create an adversarial variant if it tests distinct attack vectors not covered by the base test. Do not duplicate base test assertions with different inputs — that's redundancy, not security coverage.

Regression tests (review-surfaced bugs)

When fixing a bug surfaced by code review, swarm review, or post-merge audit, always add a regression test with the following shape so the test's purpose survives future cleanup:

describe('<feature> — regression: <one-line description> (F#)', () => {
  it('<exact behavior the bug violated>', () => {
    // Previous code did <bad thing>: e.g. the regex `/^\.\/+/` only stripped
    // a single leading `./`, so `././util.ts` survived as `./util.ts`.
    expect(normalizeGraphPath('././util.ts')).toBe('util.ts');
  });
});

Rules:

• The describe label includes the original finding ID (e.g. F8, F9, F1.1) so future readers can map back to the review.
• The leading comment in the body explains the prior buggy behavior in concrete terms — what the code did before, not what it does now.
• One regression test per finding. Do not pile unrelated assertions into a single regression block.

Regression tests must be falsifiable. Before marking regression coverage complete, temporarily remove or bypass the fix, run the regression test and confirm it fails for the expected reason, restore the fix, then rerun the test and confirm it passes. Record both commands/results in the task evidence. If the fix cannot be safely reverted, document the exact reason and use the smallest equivalent mutation that would reintroduce the bug.

Examples in-tree: tests/unit/graph/graph-query.test.ts, tests/unit/graph/import-extractor.test.ts, tests/unit/graph/graph-store.test.ts.

Guardrail Authority Tests

When testing src/hooks/guardrails/file-authority.ts or similar ordered authority checks:

• Test the specific allow/deny rule under review, not just the final denial. A later deny rule such as blockedPrefix can mask a bad earlier allow match.
• For case-sensitive glob behavior, place negative cases outside default blocked prefixes or use a custom agent with no other deny rules and explicit allowedPrefix: []. Include a positive case that the case-sensitive glob allows, and for negative cases assert the denial reason is the allowlist fallback (for example, not in allowed list) so the test proves the glob did not match.
• For generated-zone precedence, include at least one case where the filename matches the newly allowed convention under dist/ or build/.
• For custom authority arrays, pin whether the array replaces or extends defaults with tests for both an empty array and a custom non-empty array when the semantics matter.
• For matcher caches or other shared state, test both priming orders when the selected behavior depends on mode, platform, or prior calls.

FR-006: Test File Size Limit (500 lines)

scripts/check-test-file-cap.ts enforces the 500-line cap per test file (FR-006) as a diff-scoped ratchet: new test files over 500 lines and existing over-cap files that grew fail the quality gate and block PR merge. Pre-existing over-cap files not touched by the PR are non-blocking. Escape hatch: TEST_CAP_ENFORCE=0 soft-warns (use only for a deliberate growth PR).

Local validation (all platforms, including Windows)

Run the identical gate CI runs — no Bash required (issue #2078):

bun run check:test-file-cap

• Works in Windows PowerShell, macOS, and Linux; scripts/check-test-file-cap.sh is a zero-logic shim that execs the same TypeScript file, so the two entry points cannot report different results.
• The gate is diff-scoped: it compares your branch against the first of origin/main, origin/master, main, master that resolves. Run git fetch origin main first — a stale or missing base makes the comparison stale, and with no base branch resolvable the gate has nothing to compare and reports zero violations (a vacuous pass, not a real one). A branch that is behind its base is the other stale-base trap: the diff then contains the base's own commits in reverse, so counts are meaningless until you rebase.
• Directory-independent: the gate resolves the repository root itself, so running it from a subdirectory gives the same result as running it from the root.
• Exit 1 means a violation and enforcement is on; exit 0 with printed ERROR lines means you set TEST_CAP_ENFORCE=0 (soft-warn). Verify the summary counters, not just the exit code.
• The gate reads files from the working tree but takes the changed-file list from <base>..HEAD, so a new over-cap test file that is not yet committed is invisible to it. Commit before trusting a green run.

For the full splitting protocol (describe-block extraction, shared helper management, pure-function extraction, mock isolation verification, cascading-split detection), read file:.swarm/bundled-skills/test-file-split/SKILL.md.

Cross-Entry Invariants (config maps)

When you modify any entry of a "map of agents/tools/roles" in src/config/constants.ts (AGENT_TOOL_MAP, DEFAULT_MODELS, QA_AGENTS, PIPELINE_AGENTS, etc.) or tool-name registration in src/tools/tool-names.ts, there are tests that assert parity across sibling entries, not just shape of one entry.

Known parity assertions:

Workflow when adding a tool to a single agent:

1. Add the entry.
2. Run bun --smol test tests/unit/config --timeout 60000 before pushing.
3. If a parity test fails, decide: mirror the change to sibling agents, or update the invariant test if the design intent has actually changed.
4. To inspect runtime shape quickly: bun -e "import { AGENT_TOOL_MAP } from './src/config/constants.ts'; for (const [k,v] of Object.entries(AGENT_TOOL_MAP)) console.log(k, v.length);"

Debugging CI failures

When CI reports a unit (ubuntu|macos|windows) failure:

1. Identify the actual failing test from the job log first. Do not assume it's a pre-existing failure based on a local repro of a different test. Open the failing job's URL and find the <file>:<line> in the Bun output. WebFetch can scrape this if the gh CLI isn't available.
2. Reproduce that exact file locally: bun --smol test tests/unit/<dir>/<file>.test.ts --timeout 30000.
3. Then check if the same failure reproduces on main. If yes, document as pre-existing in the PR description and continue with your branch's work; do not silently inherit the failure.
4. For package-check failures: package-check validates the npm tarball (npm pack + tarball contents). A failing package-check is a source/build/package-manifest problem, not generated-file drift. dist/ is generated and NOT committed — do not stage it; run bun run build locally only when you need the bundle. There is no longer a committed-dist drift check.

Test Quality Standards

DO

• Test real behavior: call the actual function with real inputs, assert on real outputs.
• Test error paths: what happens with null, undefined, empty string, oversized input?
• Use temp directories (fs.mkdtemp) for file I/O tests. Clean up in afterEach.
• Assert on specific values, not just truthiness: expect(result.status).toBe('pending') not expect(result).toBeTruthy().

DO NOT

• Do not test type definitions. expect(event.type === 'foo').toBe(true) tests TypeScript, not your code.
• Do not test framework behavior. "Zod schema parses valid input" tests Zod, not your schema.
• Do not test test utilities. If it only exists to support other tests, it doesn't need its own test.
• Do not mock everything. If every dependency is mocked, you're testing the mock setup. Prefer real dependencies for pure functions and only mock I/O boundaries (filesystem, network, timers).
• Do not hardcode version numbers. Version bumps are automated — a test asserting version === '6.31.3' breaks on every release.
• Do not use sleep or setTimeout for synchronization. Use explicit signals, resolved promises, or Bun.sleep() with tight bounds.
• Do not spawn cat /dev/zero, yes, or other infinite-output commands. Use sleep 30 for "blocking command" tests.

Anchored Content Assertions

When asserting that skill files, protocol docs, or structured markdown contain expected text, anchor your assertions to the relevant section rather than using bare toContain() on the full file content:

// WEAK — passes even if the word appears in prose outside the intended section
expect(content).toContain('DROP');

// STRONG — fails if the structured section is removed or relocated
const stage3Start = content.indexOf('#### Stage 3: Consult Critic Sounding Board');
const stage4Start = content.indexOf('#### Stage 4: Surface User Decision Packet');
const stage3Section = content.slice(stage3Start, stage4Start);
expect(stage3Section).toContain('DROP');
expect(stage3Section).toContain('ASK_USER');

Why this matters: A bare toContain('DROP') passes as long as the word appears anywhere in the file. If the structured outcomes section is deleted but a prose reference remains (e.g., "The critic may DROP irrelevant items"), the test still passes — silently hiding the removal. Section-anchored assertions fail when the content is actually removed from its intended location.

Use this pattern for:

• Critic outcome mappings in skill files (DROP, ASK_USER, RESOLVE, REPHRASE)
• Classification category lists (self_resolved, user_decision, etc.)
• Any structured section where word presence is necessary but position-dependent

Documented-Example Regression Tests

When a SKILL.md (or other agent-facing document) contains an executable example — a tool invocation with concrete arguments, a parser output with specific field values, a protocol transcript, or any output whose shape and values are runnable — write a test that executes the actual implementation on synthetic data and compares the result field by field to the documented example. Place the test file at tests/unit/skills/<skill-name>-dry-run.test.ts (or the analogous path for the tool/parser being tested).

Why this matters: Documented examples drift from the runtime they describe, and the drift is often subtle enough to survive casual review. Common failure modes include field-name drift (ok present vs. absent; parse_errors: 0 vs. parse_errors: 2), refusal-shape drift (invocation_envelope: null in the example when the real shape is populated), value-level drift (row_index: 1 1-indexed in prose when the parser emits 0-indexed), and field-presence drift (new required fields added to an interface but omitted from the example). A field-by-field comparison test catches all of these on every CI run.

Concrete protocol:

1. Locate the executable example in the SKILL.md (tool call, parser output, protocol transcript, etc.).
2. Construct synthetic data that matches the example's input shape.
3. Run the actual implementation (parser, tool, protocol handler) on the synthetic data.
4. Assert field-by-field equality between the actual output and the documented example using bun:test's toEqual (deep-equality). Do not use loose string matching.
5. Iterate the example (or fix the implementation) until every field matches with field-level precision.

Working example: tests/unit/skills/swarm-pr-review-dry-run.test.ts exercises the swarm-pr-review SKILL.md dry-run transcript (lines 866–1050) against the live parse_lane_candidates implementation. That test survived four review cycles to align the documentation with runtime output. Drift caught during those cycles included: invocation_envelope.parse_errors was 0 in the example but actually 2 (FR-017 both-discriminators detection); invocation_envelope was null on refusal in the example but actually populated; sidecar_write_error: undefined is not valid JSON and had to be replaced with an explicit value; parse_error_details field paths and message strings did not match the parser source.

When NOT to use this pattern:

• Skills without executable examples (pure conceptual guidance with no runnable artifact).
• Examples that are intentionally schematic ("the response looks roughly like this") rather than literal.
• Documentation that is auto-generated from source — drift is impossible by construction in that case.

Cross-Platform Requirements

See also: Cross-Platform Test Patterns above for detailed guidance on mock keys, symlink behavior, temp directories, and line endings.

All tests must pass on Linux, macOS, and Windows unless explicitly gated with:

const isWindows = process.platform === 'win32';
if (isWindows) test.skip('reason', () => {});

Path handling

• Use path.join() or path.resolve(), never string concatenation with /.
• Temp directories: use os.tmpdir(), not hardcoded /tmp.
• File comparisons: normalize paths before comparing (path.resolve(a) === path.resolve(b)).

Process spawning

• Use .cmd extension on Windows for npm/bun binaries: process.platform === 'win32' ? 'bun.cmd' : 'bun'.
• Use array-form spawn/spawnSync, never shell string commands.

macOS rename-visibility race (write-then-read atomic files)

On macOS/APFS, fs.renameSync can complete before the data is visible to subsequent reads. Tests that write-then-read atomic files may fail on macos-latest but pass on ubuntu-latest and windows-latest.

Symptom: Test fails only on macOS with result === null or result === undefined immediately after a write that should have made the file visible.

Root cause: macOS filesystem updates the directory entry asynchronously after fs.renameSync. Immediately-following reads may see ENOENT or stale data.

Fix — three layers (use all three for production code):

Layer 1: Use bunWrite for atomic writes. The bunWrite function in src/utils/bun-compat.ts already handles temp file creation, fsync, atomic rename, and parent directory fsync correctly across platforms. Do NOT reimplement this pattern.

Layer 2: Add ENOENT retry in the read path. Wrap validateSwarmPath and the file read in a try/catch with a bounded retry loop for ENOENT:

// CORRECT — retry on ENOENT only (not other errors), bounded
const maxAttempts = 5;
const retryDelayMs = 10;
for (let attempt = 0; attempt < maxAttempts; attempt++) {
  try {
    const resolvedPath = _internals.validateSwarmPath(directory, filename);
    const file = bunFile(resolvedPath);
    const content = await file.text();
    return content;
  } catch (err) {
    const isNotFound = (err as NodeJS.ErrnoException)?.code === 'ENOENT';
    if (!isNotFound || attempt === maxAttempts - 1) {
      return null;
    }
    await new Promise((resolve) => setTimeout(resolve, retryDelayMs));
  }
}
return null;

CRITICAL: validateSwarmPath must be INSIDE the try block so that throws (for path traversal attempts) are caught and return null. Security tests expect readSwarmFileAsync to return null for traversal attempts.

Layer 3: Don't add arbitrary delays. setTimeout should be bounded (5-10ms, max 5 attempts). Do not add await new Promise(r => setTimeout(r, 100)) "just in case" — that's a code smell. The retry loop handles it.

See .opencode/skills/engineering-conventions/SKILL.md for the evidence file flow that triggers this retry pattern in QA gates.

Node FileHandle API

Node's FileHandle uses .sync(), NOT .fsync():

// CORRECT
const fd = await fsPromises.open(dir, 'r');
try {
  await fd.sync();
} finally {
  await fd.close();
}

// WRONG — TypeScript error: Property 'fsync' does not exist on type 'FileHandle'
const fd = await fsPromises.open(dir, 'r');
try {
  await fd.fsync();
} finally {
  await fd.close();
}

Running Tests

For the full test execution commands (bash and PowerShell per-file isolation loops, CI integration), read file:.swarm/bundled-skills/running-tests/SKILL.md. The key principle: always run one test file per process (bun --smol test <file> --timeout 30000) to prevent mock.module cross-contamination.

Before Submitting

1. Run the tests for your changed files: bun test path/to/your.test.ts
2. Run the full CI group your tests belong to (see pipeline structure above)
3. Verify no process.cwd() usage — use the directory parameter from createSwarmTool or hook constructor
4. Verify no hardcoded paths (/tmp/..., C:\...) — use os.tmpdir() + path.join()
5. Verify mocks are restored in afterEach if using spyOn or mock.module
6. Run bunx @biomejs/[email protected] check --write <touched-test-files> to auto-format only the files you created or modified. Formatting issues are a common first-pass failure — scoping the command to touched files avoids accidental workspace-wide rewrites.

Known Pre-existing Test Failures

Pre-existing and flaky failures are tracked in the per-platform quarantine ledgers (scripts/ci/quarantined-tests.txt, quarantined-tests-macos.txt, quarantined-tests-windows.txt), not in this skill. To confirm a failure is pre-existing, reproduce it in a clean worktree on origin/main (see the worktree verify protocol in running-tests).

Mock and Seam Inventories

For the current cross-module mock.module location inventory and dead-code _internals seam inventory, read references/mock-and-seam-inventory.md.